Redemption of ’Bama’s Jalen Hurts illustrates what sports teach us

By David McElroy · December 2, 2018

If the story had been written for a Hollywood movie, it would have been rejected as completely unbelievable. But Alabama backup quarterback Jalen Hurts showed Saturday night what it means to fight through adversity and doubt to come back as a winner when his team needed him. In doing so, he showed the best of what sports can teach all of us.

Just 11 months ago, Hurts was on top of the college football world. He was 26-2 as a two-year starter at quarterback for Alabama. He had brought the Crimson Tide to the national championship game against Georgia, but by halftime, it was clear that he wasn’t getting the job done. Coach Nick Saban started relatively untested freshman Tua Tagovailoa in the second half when Hurts couldn’t generate any offense. From the sideline, Hurts enthusiastically supported his teammates and earned respect from a lot of people — including me — as he watched Tagovailoa lead a comeback win in overtime for the national championship.

During the offseason, there was a lot of buzz about who would start at quarterback for Alabama this year. Hurts and Tagovailoa competed during spring practice and pre-season practice. To the surprise of no one, Tagovailoa won the starting job. He has been the most dominant player in the college game this year and has been considered the frontrunner for the Heisman Trophy most of the year.

It had to have been humiliating for Hurts to see a new kid get all the glory he had received at Alabama for two years.

Hurts could have pouted about losing his starting job. He might have let everyone know he didn’t deserve to be treated this way. He could have loudly criticized coaches for not choosing him. Mostly, he could have transferred to another school. Many people encouraged him to transfer. In fact, he could have even left the team after the first few games to save a year of eligibility. (When starting quarterback Kelly Bryant lost his job at Clemson in the first couple of games, that’s what he did. He quit the team to transfer, leaving Clemson without a decent backup quarterback.)

But Hurts did none of those things.

As Alabama rolled up huge offensive numbers this years — put up by the man who beat him for the job — Hurts would go into the game late for mop-up duty. He never played a snap of football this year that mattered — until Saturday night in the SEC championship game.

In the same stadium in Atlanta where he lost his starting job last January — against the same team — Hurts finally got another chance Saturday night.

Tagovailoa hurt his ankle in the first quarter and was ineffective for most of the game. By the fourth quarter, the same ankle was stepped on and he had to leave the game — with Alabama losing and seemingly destined for its first loss of the year.

With Tagovailoa out of the game, Saban sent Hurts into the game and told him, “This is your time, buddy.”

You can read the specifics of how he did it if you don’t already know, but Hurts first led the team to a tying touchdown. After the Alabama defense stopped Georgia, Hurts drove the offense again, this time for the winning touchdown, running the final 15 yards to the end zone himself.

Last year, it was a jubilant Hurts cheering from the sideline as his teammate led Alabama to a win. This year, it was a grimacing Tagovailoa cheering Hurts from the sideline as he completed his redemption story. (In the photo above, you can see pain on Tagovailoa’s face as he embraces Hurts after the win.)

There are a lot of things we can learn in life from books, but there are some things we learn best from competing with each other. There are things we learn about ourselves from winning and there are other things we learn about ourselves from losing. The lessons from losing are sometimes more important.

Sports have the power to teach us a lot of lessons. Some of those lessons have to be learned from playing the games. Others can be learned from watching others and getting involved in their stories.

Kirk Herbstreit learned a lot of lessons as a defender at Ohio State and he’s now one of ESPN’s most insightful game commentators. After Alabama’s win Saturday night, he tweeted this about Hurts: “What an INCREDIBLE example for kids out there that think leaving for greener pastures after seeing the first sign of adversity is the answer!! Jalen Hurts has shown amazing fortitude all year and has been an AMAZING leader and SUPPORTER of his teammates! And NOW saves his team’s dreams!”

CBS Sports tweeted this summary of the Hurts story after the game:

Jalen Hurts could’ve left Alabama after being benched.
He could’ve sulked.
He didn’t.
He stayed ready.
He delivered when his team needed him.
He’s achieved the ultimate redemption.

I didn’t play any team sports as I was growing up — unless you count the academic team and the math team, which isn’t quite the same thing. I didn’t learn to value sports until I started covering the stories while I was in college. I soon understood the deeply important lessons that sports can teach. (Sports can have ugly sides, too, but that’s a different issue.)

Watching Jalen Hurts fail so publicly but then fight his way back — supporting his teammates and being a respected leader the whole time — is an inspiration to me. It’s the sort of story that makes me eager to get up and try one more time to run through walls that have blocked me before. And it makes me hope my future children can learn positive lessons themselves by playing some sport.

I don’t know what Hurts will do in the future. He earns his degree from Alabama later this month and might very well transfer elsewhere for his final year of eligibility. Nobody would question that, especially since Tagovailoa will be back and several highly recruited quarterbacks are on their way. Hurts might play elsewhere. He might even get a shot at an NFL career.

But whatever he does, he will be well-served by the lesson he’s learned this year — lessons that we can learn with him:

Persevere when the time is right.

Don’t whine when you lose.

Don’t blame others when you fail.

Keep working to get better.

Be a good teammate and leader.

Keep yourself ready — because your chance might very well come when you least expect it.

Share on Social Networks

Do antidepressants work? It depends on who you ask and what standards you use. But a new Danish study concludes we just don’t know. There’s no question antidepressants make chemical changes in the brain, but the truth is that doctors don’t know enough about those brain processes to do anything more than try certain drugs and see what they do. The Danish study says that if antidepressants do help, the effects are tiny. I know plenty of people who swear they couldn’t live without their antidepressants, but the more I study about the root causes of depression, the more I suspect the placebo effect is what’s going on. Although some studies suggest these drugs have slight positive effects for some people, others argue that the positive effects are tiny — and that they cause more deaths than can be explained. There’s nothing wrong with using any drug that helps with something wrong with us — especially short term — but I’m coming to suspect that whatever good SSRIs and similar drugs do comes from masking our underlying issues, not fixing them. Denial is popular with humans, so it will be no surprise if this eventually turns out to be true.

Your brain has almost certainly tricked you into making bad romantic choices. A California psychology professor writes in Psychology Today that there are four things our brains do that cause trouble: 1) We think we know what we want — but we don’t. I’ve seen this in myself and if you haven’t seen it yet, you will. The things I wanted in a mate when I was young are completely different from what the mature version of myself wants. 2) We like more choices — as many as possible. We tend to believe that more choices lead to a better selection in all sorts of areas, but the truth is that too many choices tend to lead to the paralysis of failure to choose. 3) We try to be rational by “keeping our options open.” We’re scared to make the choices we need to make, because we’re scared of doing the wrong thing. This keeps us trapped in bad situations — and better choices eventually disappear. 4) We stay with the wrong people, because we don’t want our effort to go to waste. I’ve done this. Maybe you have, too. On several occasions, I’ve stayed in a relationship that I knew was dead and needed to end. At this point in my life, I know to trust my gut. It’s a lot smarter about most things than my conscious brain.

I just noticed that I’m approaching 3,000 subscribers for this site again. Although I’ve had plenty of individual days with far higher readership, the core of any site is those readers who are interested enough to subscribe and keep coming back. In the days when I wrote about politics, I hit 3,000 subscribers at my peak, but once I shifted focus, those subscribers started dropping like flies. These days, the readership numbers are still lower than they were when I wrote about politics, but I think it’s a better quality reader — people who are interested in something more important to long-term happiness than politics will ever be. I don’t know if I’ll hit 30,000 readers in one day anytime soon — as I did one day years ago when Rush Limbaugh and several conservative commentators linked to me — but I appreciate those of you who keep coming back again and again. I can’t thank you individually — and I don’t even know who you are — but I want you to know that I really appreciate you.

Few things threaten the future of the human race as much as the decline of the widespread ability to read words and evaluate them rationally. This has become a culture dominated by images and emotions, which scares me because our freedom and our wealth were built on ideas and rational thinking. Not so long ago, it was considered vital for every person to be able to read coherent arguments and respond to them with intelligence and reason. Today, emotions trump reason and images trump words. When Neil Postman published “Amusing Ourselves to Death” in 1985, he made the argument that the age of television was slowly destroying Americans’ ability to reason. Postman is long dead, but it turns out that he and other academics such as Marshall McLuhan saw where things were going far before words started falling out of favor. I beg you to read Postman’s short and clear book, but if you won’t invest that much time, at least consider this article about news today. In “Could I have some news with my emotions, please?” a former NBC News executive bemoans the sad state of “emotion over information” in television news. I believe “television news” is an oxymoron, but I’ll leave that for another time.

UPDATE: For about 18 hours, I thought I had made a serious mistake at work last month that had sent a couple thousand dollars to the wrong party. When a problem was discovered last night, the data available to us in our accounting system made it seem certain that I had made that error. I felt sick. I was humiliated. Even though I’ve handled hundreds of real estate transactions for my company — millions of dollars — without ever making an error, I felt shame that I had made this one mistake. But it turns out that an anomaly in our accounting software was hiding the truth. Once I got to the office Thursday and reviewed the paperwork from the transaction, I discovered that I had done everything correctly. It’s great that I didn’t make the mistake, but it would be even better if I could learn not to have such horrible physical reactions of shame and fear just because someone else believes I’ve made an error. The fear of being flawed is very powerful for me. Old programming from childhood is hard to change.

Related Posts