How did so many people ever fall for the fiction that “self government” means being governed by the majority of one’s neighbors? Being governed by some powerful elite is bad, but being governed by the “non-powerful masses” is just another brand of poison. Self-governance means just that — governing yourself.
Of all the national myths in this country, perhaps none is as nonsensical as the notion that there is a collective “genius of the American people” insofar as governance goes. It’s a myth that’s discussed in almost religious tones — and it leaves otherwise intelligent people acting in foolish ways to try to bring about things that aren’t possible.
I started thinking about this Wednesday because of a Cato Institute policy forum I listened to called “Citizens v. the Ruling Elite.” (You can watch the video of the forum at the end of this article. Or click here to subscribe to Cato’s audio podcasts via iTunes. Many of them are excellent.) The theme of the discussion was finding ways to elect people to Congress who would “represent the people” instead of elites.
One of the speakers was a co-founder of one of the Tea Party groups. Another speaker was with an organization working to get more people to run in party primaries to challenge incumbents. (On the pragmatic side, the group working for more primary challenges is just plain wrong to believe that this is a good way to defeat incumbents, but that’s a different story entirely.) The overall theme for all the presentations is that the people in office now represent “the elites,” but that if the right candidates would just run, “the people” would suddenly be represented and everything would change.
Since these people believe this, I wonder what other fairy tales they believe.
Just a performance: actors and politicians have a lot in common
Was he angry to lose his family? Or because he lost his control?
Thirst for love and understanding drives all of us until it’s quenched
My father’s narcissistic control left me resentful of all authority
Health risk and social costs make drinking alcohol a very poor risk
Unjustified panic: Why are you so scared of all the wrong things?
We can’t defeat the existing system; we must build a better one instead
When did someone decide we have the legal right not to be offended?
After man’s death, family leaves server $500 tip to fulfill his wish