Are you a good person? Or a bad person? Are you capable of theft? Deception? Murder? Is it a black-and-white question? Or is the answer a lot more gray — for all of us?
One of my favorite podcasts of 2014 was a spinoff of This American Life called Serial. In 12 episodes, the show explored a 15-year-old murder case, seeking to answer the question of whether the right man is in prison for the crime. (If you haven’t heard the show, I recommend it.)
In one of the final episodes of the season, the reporter spent a tremendous amount of time going over and over the question of whether the guy in prison seems like a killer or not. She seemed tormented by the need to know whether the man she had been interviewing could possibly have committed the murder.
She seemed obsessed with answering that question. Was this guy capable of murder?
I think she was asking the wrong question, so let me set it up in a different way. Let’s talk about you instead of the man sitting in prison for a murder which I suspect he didn’t commit.
Let’s say there’s something you want badly. I don’t just mean a new television or a boat or even a fancy house. I’m talking about something you’re emotionally committed to. Maybe it’s a woman who you’re in love with. (Or a man.) Maybe it’s some money that you think is rightfully yours. Maybe it’s some position of prestige or power that you believe should be yours.
With all of those things, let’s say that you want the person or thing, but there’s one other person standing in your way. Would you kill that person to get what you desperately want?

Maybe it’s easier to do hard things when nobody says they’re difficult
Nature struggles to keep alive
Can a free society tolerate intrusions into details of ‘The Lives of Others’?
Arrogance and stupidity go hand in hand for the coercive state
We have a hunger for love just as strong as the need for food, water
Reality frequently doesn’t match fantasy when you know full story
Without hope for a better future, depression grabs us by the throat
Years later, I see that I was an outsider who could never fit in
After chimp’s mother died, mama dog raised baby as one of her pups