• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

David McElroy

making sense of a dysfunctional culture

  • About David
  • New here?
  • Reading
  • Video

The biggest question a human faces is how to live a good life

By David McElroy · June 6, 2026

A baby isn’t born with an owner’s manual.

Human beings are born into all sorts of circumstances. Some come into loving homes. Some face challenges that make life confusing.

When children are young, they’re under the control of adults who seem god-like in many ways. The adults seem to know everything. They seem to have complete control. We eventually figure out that those adults are typically just as confused as we are, but in the meantime, we absorb everything those adults teach.

Some of what we’re taught is intentional, but much of it is what we pick up from the examples around us. Both good and bad.

By the time a child is in the neighborhood of 18 years old, he or she is considered an adult. The child has spent years trying to define himself or herself in relation to parents, assuming those figures are around. At first, most children want to be just like their parents, but the time soon comes when they want to pull away and live their own lives.

By the time I was in my 20s, I knew everything. Or so I thought. I really thought I had everything figured out. Most people feel the same, either consciously or unconsciously. And then we’re off to building a life as a new adult.

But in all of that messy process, one thing is true for almost all of us. Since we don’t have an owner’s manual, we’ve been programmed by parents and preachers and teachers.

Nobody has ever told us that we need to ask one basic question: How should I live a good life?

That sounds mundane, but it’s not.

Culture invisibly brainwashes us about what a good life is. Parents and preachers and teachers can modify that programming, but people living in a media-centric age absorb the vast majority of what they believe — about the world and about themselves — from that media culture.

It’s very difficult — and very rare — for a typical young person to question what he or she has been taught. So the question of what constitutes a good life — and how this particular individual ought to live — is rarely asked in a serious manner.

You basically have two broad approaches.

One approach is down the path of inherited answers. The other approach leads down a path to consciously chosen answers.

You can select the off-the-shelf package of answers that your culture gives you. You can accept those answers and maybe modify them a little bit to suit your purposes.

Or you can reject what the culture gives you and you can design your own answers for your own life.

The first path is the default choice for everyone in our culture. It’s the path of least resistance. Since everyone else is doing it — copying the norms that are presented in movies, television, music and social media — that seems like the obvious right choice.

For most people, it’s not even a choice. It’s just the only obvious reality.

But when you look around in our current dysfunctional culture and see how miserable the average person is today, it seems far more reasonable to reject what the culture is selling and ask yourself that simple question.

How should I live a good life?

You have a limited number of years and days and hours. You don’t know exactly how many, but you can pull a number out of the air. Let’s say you’re going to live 90 years.

If that’s the time you have, how do you need to invest those years in order to be able to look back at the end of them and feel as though you lived well?

If you follow the path that’s programmed into you by your culture, you will spend most of those years chasing things that the culture tells you are important. You will pursue money, possessions, prestige, pleasure and ego-satisfaction.

Those pursuits are incredibly time-consuming. Look at the people around you. How many do you see on an endless treadmill that promises those things will eventually show up if they run harder and harder?

How many do you know who would like the time to pursue more important things — happy families, spiritual development, more loving connections — but who never quite get around to it? How many do you know who are so exhausted from living a “normal life” that they never quite find the time to give more than lip service to something deeper in life?

Here’s the thing. Living the way the world teaches you to live is time-consuming. Living the way a wiser person might live is also time-consuming.

The brutal truth is that you can’t do both.

If there were an owner’s manual for a human being, it would teach us this. It would explain that the money and pleasure and possessions are going to seem pretty empty and sterile if we allow those things to dominate our lives.

Such an owner’s manual would explain that in order to have the things which will ultimately matter in life — love, spiritual riches, close connections to others — we have to sacrifice much of what the culture tells us to chase. Actually, the longer I live, the more I think we have to reject pretty much all of what the culture tells us to chase.

The most powerful teacher I have had in life has been failure.

When I was young, I wanted to be wealthy and powerful. I wanted money and success and public adulation.

The older I got, the more I saw how little those things mattered to me. But I was able to notice that truth simply because I had moments of intense failure — when I was forced to look myself in the mirror and ask myself what really mattered.

I can’t tell you exactly what should matter to you. I’ve been bold enough — maybe even arrogant enough — to write quite a bit over the years about what can contribute to a good life. I think I have some powerful reasons and some powerful evidence in favor of the conclusions I’ve drawn.

But whether you agree with all of my conclusions or not, I think it’s inarguable that the path presented by our culture is spiritually bankrupt. It’s a cruel path that leads to a wasted life.

I’ve been hard-headed about giving up all that I was brainwashed to believe.

I wanted to hold onto the notion that I could sit on the fence, one foot in each world. I wanted to believe that I could have a good bit of what the culture offers to me and still have the time and energy to pursue things that mattered more deeply.

It’s only been in the last few years that I’ve given up on the lies I was taught.

I no longer care about the things the culture thinks matter. I spend more and more of my time doing things that truly matter to me. I no longer feel the need to justify my choices. I no longer feel ashamed of saying, “No, I don’t want the things you have in your life — not because they wouldn’t be nice to have, but because the price is too high.”

I wish I had had an owner’s manual to teach me these things when I was young. I like to think I would have listened, but maybe I’m fooling myself.

Either way, I understand now what matters. And what doesn’t matter. I’ve re-arranged my life to give the years and months and days that I have left to the things I believe genuinely matter.

Your conclusions about what actually matters might end up differing from mine. That’s fine. There’s nothing magical or infallible about my own conclusions.

But I’m begging you not to take the unthinking default choices offered by the culture. I’m begging you to ask yourself — in a very serious way — what it would take for you to live a good life.

Share on Social Networks

Related Posts

  • Ten years later, it hurts to know she lost faith in me and gave up
  • Lonely older man finds new life through meeting and loving dogs
  • What can a free society do before an unstable person commits a crime?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

My Instagram

For those who are in places where it’s miserably h For those who are in places where it’s miserably hot today, here is a minute of light rain and gentle thunder from my back yard late Saturday afternoon. It’s very relaxing to stand at my back door and watch this, especially since the heat is pretty mild today — 80 degrees (about 26 celsius) — for July in the American South.
Alex was willing to cooperate with me for a new po Alex was willing to cooperate with me for a new portrait late Wednesday night. It’s been roughly three and a half years now since the cold night when I was able to lure him out from behind a garbage dumpster into a trap — but I don’t think he’s sorry at this point that he fell for the trick. 😺
This is the face of a man who’s thrilled that the This is the face of a man who’s thrilled that the weekend is finally here. It was a very long (and productive) week, but the time has finally come that I have time to write and read and think. Late Friday night, I’m at the McDonald’s near my house with a Diet Dr Pepper and a MacBook. For me, it’s like Cheers without the booze.
Donald Trump has figured out who to blame for the Donald Trump has figured out who to blame for the the D.C. Reflecting Pool turning green. The dastardly deed was carried out by a specially trained squad of Antifa cats trained by the Far Left. It’s not his fault. Arrest all the cats! #satire #parody
This was the sunset that faced me as I left Walmar This was the sunset that faced me as I left Walmart near my house just a few minutes ago. It was a beautiful light show for just a few minutes.
Here’s proof that reality and satire are indisting Here’s proof that reality and satire are indistinguishable these days.
This was the sunset I saw from the parking lot out This was the sunset I saw from the parking lot outside of the Walmart near my house just after the sun went down Friday evening.
This little parody was inspired by my trip to buy This little parody was inspired by my trip to buy gas a little while ago. Even at a no-name brand, the price was $4.09. If I remember correctly, it was $2.29 a gallon at the same station on the day the war started. I don’t know about you, but I’m tired of winning. 🤣
For the best and most sophisticated in lawn care, For the best and most sophisticated in lawn care, check out the sponsor of one of my upcoming YouTube video episodes. 🙃 #parody #threestooges
Follow on Instagram

Critter Instagram

Alex posed for me briefly as I was leaving the hou Alex posed for me briefly as I was leaving the house Monday afternoon, but he just wanted assurances that I’d be back by his dinner time. He said the rest of his day is booked solid with naps, so he didn’t want to be worrying about whether I’d be late again.
From the CritterCam: In this brief clip, Alex walk From the CritterCam: In this brief clip, Alex walks past his bed — on my desk — and decides to make the mighty leap to the nearby castle instead. It’s a dark and rainy day, so the office looks very dark.
Sam is watching me from a dark corner of the bedro Sam is watching me from a dark corner of the bedroom at midnight.
From the CritterCam: I’m not there to see what has From the CritterCam: I’m not there to see what has Alex’s attention, but something outside an office window has him concerned enough to sit up in bed. His beauty sleep is disturbed now.
A few minutes after 2 a.m., Oliver was relaxing in A few minutes after 2 a.m., Oliver was relaxing in my arms when he suddenly noticed that Alex was stalking him. He went into hurter mode himself and launched himself at Alex about 30 seconds after this. They’re not chasing each other back and forth between the office and the bedroom, leaving Sam as a bewildered observer.
From the CritterCam: Alex seems despondent that he From the CritterCam: Alex seems despondent that he hasn’t had his dinner yet Saturday night and I’m not home for him to complain about this injustice. The service gets worse and worse in this feline restaurant. There must be some law against this sort of abuse. 😺
Late Friday night, Sam was peacefully hanging out Late Friday night, Sam was peacefully hanging out in my lap, but as soon as I started talking about him being with me, he suddenly made a mighty leap and he was gone. This is short and is mostly funny — to me, anyway — because he seemed so eager to contradict what I was in the process of saying. 😺
From the CritterCam: Oliver seems to have taken ov From the CritterCam: Oliver seems to have taken over the cat bed on my desk this evening. I’m betting that I’ll find Alex on top of the castle instead, but the fact that I find myself thinking about this on the way home from work says a lot about my unorthodox priorities in life. 😺
From the CritterCam: I have no idea what was outsi From the CritterCam: I have no idea what was outside an office window to catch Alex’s attention — birds, maybe? — but he briefly looked very intrigued.
Follow on Instagram

Contact David

David likes email, but can’t reply to every message. I get a surprisingly large number of requests for relationship advice — seriously — but time doesn’t permit a response to all of them. (Sorry.)

Subscribe

Enter your address to receive notifications by email every time new articles are posted. Then click “Subscribe.”

Search

Donations

If you enjoy this site and want to help, click here. All donations are appreciated, no matter how large or small. (PayPal often doesn’t identify donors, so I might not be able to thank you directly.)




Archives

Secondary Sidebar

Briefly

It turns out that the radical far left has been training “Antifa cats” to sabotage anything important to Donald Trump. Everything he did was perfect. Honest. It was all the cats’ fault. Arrest all the cats! This is the latest of my ridiculous satirical shorts. Please go watch it. Then “like” it and subscribe. Please. I’m begging you. (Too much?) Although a couple of the previous videos have had views in the hundreds, most have still been seen by fewer than 20 people. So I seem to be having trouble letting people know that page exists.

Here’s the latest of my ridiculous parody shorts. It crossed my mind Tuesday to wonder what a slick and fast-talking car dealer might do right now to try to turn the high price of gasoline to his advantage. So I conceived of a fat and lovable character who tried to sell cars that don’t use any fuel — and then I started wondering if it would be funnier if all the characters were felines. Designing the King Cashpaw character took about four hours, but the rest took only another four hours, so this was a relatively quick piece that virtually wrote itself. I know it’s almost impossible for these parody videos to find a larger audience, but at least they amuse me — and there are 19 of them on my YouTube page now. The first few were very limited, but they’re getting more complex.

The Republican Party is dead. It still exists in name, of course, but it’s nothing but a shell. All that’s left are idiots and stooges and con men of the MAGA party. When Donald Trump is gone — which won’t be long — those populist idiots and pragmatic fools will have no one to follow. Democrats will thrive. They will take more power than ever and they will push the federal government further to the radical far left than ever. When that happens, don’t just blame Trump if you’re a conservative. Blame every person who has claimed to be a conservative and has given up on principles, character and everything else that Republicans once claimed to stand for. As someone who worked as a GOP political consultant for many years, this is disgusting and disturbing to me. Those who have enabled Trump to have almost unchecked power are going to be shocked when they see what they will unleash in the long run. It’s been plain all along what this narcissistic con man is. It’s your fault that you chose to pretend not to see what he really is.

We are ruled by the dumbest and most incompetent people among us — and we have a system which allows stupid and irresponsible people to force the costs of their idiocy onto smarter and wiser people. Can we get away with that? Yes, for quite some time. But we eventually reach a point at which the dumbest of the dumb — who are habitual liars and mentally ill fools — lead us to the disasters and destruction that some of us have seen coming for years. We are approaching that point. And yet most of the idiots around us still wave their rhetorical banners of support for the evil people who are leading us to ruin — and all of them point their fingers at someone else, never noticing that their own enthusiastic support of evil is to blame. When things finally fall apart, blame yourself for your blindness to the evil, not whoever happens to be in power when it happens.

I’ve been making some changes to the site lately and there are more changes coming in the days ahead, so don’t be surprised if you some small differences. This is not a wholesale redesign, but rather the addition of some features. Since they’re smarter than I am, I’ve put Oliver and Alex in charge of the technical work, which you can see in this action photo from the control room of our media complex. I recently added a series of landing pages for readers who randomly discover the site from an Internet search. I’ve also changed the YouTube link at the top of the page to go to the new YouTube channel for video essays that reflect things I’ve already published here. (Here’s a little bit about both of the YouTube channels I’m working on.) In addition, I’m trying to move away from using Instagram, so I’m experimenting with photo plug-ins that will eventually allow me to host the pictures — cats, dogs, sunsets, whatever — that I often take. So don’t be surprised to see more changes. Thanks for your patience. Let’s hope Alex and Oliver know what they’re doing.

Read More

Crass Capitalism

Before you buy anything from Amazon, please click on this link. I’ll get a tiny commission, but it won’t cost you a nickel extra. The cats will thank you. And so will I.

© 2011–2026 · All Rights Reserved
Built by: 1955 DESIGN