If there’s something wrong in the world, there’s one sure-fire way to make it worse — put the federal government in charge of it. Yet that’s what the White House and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid want to do to fix Internet security.
The plan from Senate Democrats would give the Department of Homeland Security the power to tell businesses how to run their Internet security. Putting the people behind the TSA in charge of security would be like giving Deputy Barney Fife the power to tell banks how to design security to outwit masterminds.
Computer professionals aren’t happy with the news. According to the writer of CIO.com’s IT Security Hack blog:
“And, as with much legislation, it basically extends government power without actually improving anything. Businesses already know hacking is costing them money – this is really the only incentive needed for them. Fortunately and unsurprisingly, a lot of industry groups are lobbying against this because of the additional costs it would mean. What businesses really want is a law that would give them legal protections so they can share information with authorities without risking antitrust or privacy violations.”
The federal government has been “fixing” health care for the last 50 years or so. Everything it’s done so far has made things even worse, despite the good intentions that are invoked each time the government takes more control over the system. And then when those changes have unintended consequences of making things worse, the “solution” is to demand even more power to fix things. The real solution is to get government out of the way and let the market work. It’s the same way with the Internet.
Want to return to a simpler world? Say ‘goodbye’ to cheeseburgers
It might not matter who’s right; just fix the problem and move on
In ’98, Ron Paul warned U.S. policy was leading to terrorist attacks
Some Ohio State football fans believe a U.S. president has superpowers
I’m not certain artists ever get to be themselves when they perform
Pursuit of perfection leaves me feeling shame when I’m flawed
Federal control of Internet security would put Barney Fife in charge
Why does the mainstream ignore those whose predictions were right?