We learned Saturday that 30 American troops (along with seven Afghans) were killed Friday night when Afghan rebels shot their helicopter down during a raid. The obvious question: Why are U.S. troops still there?
Afghanistan is no danger to the United States today, and it’s not our business to fix the country’s twisted political situation. I don’t see any evidence that it’s even realistically possible, especially considering that Afghanistan has a long history of humiliating invaders. Ask the British and the Russians about that.
So why are U.S. troops still fighting over this inhospitable piece of land where the people don’t like each other very much and like us even less? Many people would give many different justifications for the continuing war. (You do realize that it’s been going on for almost 10 years now, don’t you?) Some people would claim that if U.S. troops pulled out that terrorists would be able to go back to using the country as a safe haven. Others would say the U.S. needs to stay there to build a stable and democratic government. Others would be more honest and just say that since we started the fight, we have to gain a complete victory or else lose face.
All of the listed reasons are bogus. The real reason the U.S. military is still there is that war itself is good for the state, even though that’s not necessarily the conscious intent of the politicians making the decisions. In fact, many of them have spent their careers opposing U.S. involvement in wars, but when you reach a position of power — especially something such as the U.S. presidency — you frequently end up making decisions that reflect the permanent interests of the state.
‘Run away with me?’ I couldn’t accept her offer, but I wanted to
Rights or choices? It might be time to re-frame the debate
THE McELROY ZOO: Meet Bessie, the beautiful girl who’s still scared
Our choices determine whether we die alone or surrounded by love
If elections could bring freedom, voting would have been outlawed
Unless you’re suicidal, an armed march on D.C. is a very bad idea
Step in the right direction: U.S. ad group bans cosmetic photoshopping
Most prizes feel empty, because our real need is for connection
What happened when a coach valued discipline over winning?