Valentine’s Day in this culture is all about love stories and feel-good fantasy. But what about those of us who don’t have love — those of us whose hearts are broken by need and emptiness?
For me, love has been closely associated with painful longing recently. I’m torn about what to think about this, because I feel something strongly that I perceive as the truth, but some psychologists and writers say that’s not healthy.
“Deep painful longing, yearning and craving are not characteristics of love,” writes Shari Schreiber, for instance. “If you think they are, you were emotionally programmed to believe this in childhood, when you couldn’t get your adoration for mother returned.”
If I’m deceiving myself about love, then our culture is filled with music from people who are similarly deceived by their longing. For Valentine’s Day, I’ve created a list of 10 songs that fall into that category. These aren’t songs about happy love. These are songs for those of us who are alone — and who are longing for love we can’t have.

A broken heart is devastating, but closing yourself to love is worse
Past feels like blurry watercolor, not like the history of real people
As nightmares plague my friends, I’m grateful mine have subsided
Timeless design principles beat suburban McMansions for beauty
Apologize while you still can, because you’ll live with regret
VIDEO: Today marks three years with the ruler of my household
If you aren’t free to to be a bigot if you choose, you’re not really free
Is it abuse to force atypical kids to conform to norms of society?